Hold the Pickles, Hold the Lettuce…

Fast food restaurants are famous for doing market research to pinpoint their customers’ needs, but what teen consumers are looking for in a novel is sometimes obscured by assumptions on the part of Young Adult writers.

Most authors know that teenagers like to read books about kids who are a few years older than themselves, and that girls will read “boy books,” but boys don’t usually like to read “girl books” (at least in public). Beyond that, many writers seem to think that if their protagonist is a young adult, the manuscript qualifies as YA.

In fact, there are numerous aspects to consider when penning a developmentally appropriate novel. Teens usually enjoy works in which they can identify with the protagonist, but in situations that are out of the ordinary. They like to see how a character tackles a problem, and then reflect on what they might have done in a similar situation. Coming-of-age stories are always popular, as are stories where teens somehow best the adults, or prove themselves through adversity, or fight and win an underdog cause, or find out that something they’d been led to believe isn’t true. Good vs. evil and the suspense of a character making the “right” choice instead of the “wrong” one seems to hold a particular fascination.

“Young Adult” is currently defined by the American Library Association as ranging in age from 10-25. Many writers informally classify their work as “Young YA” or “Mature YA,” because of the disparity in emotional development within that age group.* Ignoring this aspect of the genre can actually be detrimental to the reader. One of my sisters, a pediatric nurse, recently attended a lecture given by a psychologist who said it is not uncommon for teens to experience intense anxiety and other problems because of reading material that they aren’t emotionally ready for.**

There’s a lot to think about when authoring content for that diverse group, and writers need to make sure that their product is suitable for the target market. Fast food chains are coming under fire for providing what kids want at the expense of what is healthful. No one expects them to serve broccoli, but with a little creativity, they should be able to come up with something nourishing that also satisfies the palate.

*See my previous post, “Considering Asychronous Development in Book Selection.”

**Victoria Mixon just blogged about this topic on June 15th, and it’s worth a read.



Filed under Critical Thinking, Miscellaneous, Reading, Uncategorized, Writing

5 responses to “Hold the Pickles, Hold the Lettuce…

  1. Excellent post, Layinda. And so needed. In today’s world it seems we’re inundating kids with inappropriate movies, games, books, etc. Some (most?) kids just aren’t ready for it.

  2. So very true! Teens are much more complex and much more thoughtful than many people give them credit for. If the story doesn’t reach for that complexity, the story isn’t going to sell.

  3. I must admit, I’ve never been clear on what constitutes YA. I wouldn’t classify A Catcher in the Rye as YA, for example, despite it being a coming-of-age book in many ways.

  4. Amen.

    My daughter is on the very young end of YA and some of what she wants to read is definitely on the opposite end of that maturity spectrum.

    It takes a lot of parental vigilance to make sure they read appropriate material and discuss all the questions and concerns that arise from the books they are reading.

    Thanks for highlighting such an important topic.

  5. Me again – I’ve got an award for you over at my blog 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s