Cover Up: New Looks for Old Books

Product Details Product Details

Ironically, after I rhapsodized about my Christmastime search for the perfect book, my younger son wasn’t as wild about Ribsy as I had hoped. At first.

When I’d found it at the bookstore, I was dismayed that the cover had been updated, but had no idea that it would impact my son. The dynamic black and white image of Ribsy on a yellow ground was replaced at some point by a generic short hair, and had I been wandering the bookstore aimlessly, I would not even have picked it up. Why, I wondered, would they replace the original Ribsy: large, lanky, and shedding exactly the sort of personality that would end up riding away in the wrong car?

Ribsy is not the only victim. Most of Beverly Cleary’s book covers have been updated, as have Elizabeth Enright’s, Edward Eager’s, Madeleine L’Engle’s and many others. Sometimes, the illustrators don’t even seem acquainted with the characters they’re trying to portray. It is easy to imagine an art director saying, “Hey, we need a scruffy dog on the cover. Go with red or blue — yellow’s been done.”

Even when the new covers aren’t bad, it would be a stretch to say they are an improvement. Consider All of a Kind Family, by Sydney Taylor,

Product DetailsMarguerite Henry’s Brighty of the Grand Canyon,

Product DetailsBrighty: Of the Grand Canyon (Marguerite Henry Horseshoe Library)or Elizabeth George Speare’s The Witch of Blackbird Pond.

The Witch of Blackbird Pond Publisher: Houghton Mifflin CompanyThe Witch of Blackbird Pond

I am a firm believer in, “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” If the original cover attracted readers in the first place, why mess with success?

Interestingly, even when covers are changed, inside illustrations frequently remain the same, such as Jean Merrill’s The Toothpaste MillionaireThe Toothpaste Millionaire,The Toothpaste Millionaire

and Elizabeth Enright’s The Saturdays.

The SaturdaysThe Saturdays (Melendy Quartet)

One wonders about the point of having an updated cover, especially when it is labeled, “With pictures by the original illustrator.”

Thankfully, not all old titles have lost their looks. The recently reprinted Happy Hollisters The Happy Hollisters
books have maintained their original covers and illustrations, and the classic Nancy Drew  series (although updated from the 1940s) has remained unchanged for decades.

On some level, even the publishers must think that newer doesn’t necessarily mean better. For the 100th anniversary edition of Anne of Green Gables, Putnam went with the original cover,

Anne of Green Gables, 100th Anniversary Edition
as did Harcourt for the 50th anniversary of Edward Eager’s Half Magic.
Half Magic: Fiftieth-Anniversary Edition

Yearling seems to have realized that The Wolves of Willoughby Chase got it right the first time,

Product Details  The Wolves of Willoughby Chase (The Wolves Chronicles)

and Goodnight Moon‘s original cover (1947) is still going strong.

Goodnight Moon

The whole concept of updating could ultimately prove to be a slippery slope. Until the recent Twain tom-foolery, no one had considered changing the text, but now, who knows?

Adventures of Huckleberry Finn - Original Unabridged VersionThe Adventures of Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain, Alfred Kazin, Alfred Kazin (Afterword)

Perhaps soon, other old favorites will have not only language, but plot points updated to jibe with the newest generation of readers. Meg Murray might start to “disrespect” Mrs. Whatsit, whilst Charles Wallace sits staring at his gaming system instead of a giant pulsing brain.

After several attempts to get my son to read Ribsy, it occurred to me that perhaps he was trying to tell a book by its cover. “Let me show you what Ribsy really looks like,” I said as I went online to show him the original.  “Do you want to read it now?”

“Yes! He looks like a fun pup.” He ran to his room to get it, then shouted down the stairs, “Why didn’t you buy me THAT book?”

A Wrinkle in Time (Madeleine L'Engle's Time Quintet)

Half MagicProduct Details

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under Critical Thinking, Miscellaneous, Reading, Recommended Reading, Uncategorized

One response to “Cover Up: New Looks for Old Books

  1. Christine

    This is nice. I agree with it. Thank you for sharing this to us.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s